If you’re a mortgage broker trying to grow in 2025, here’s some tough love: half the “advice” you hear in this industry is total BS. It's outdated, misapplied, or based on someone else’s personal formula and that formula may not even work anymore.
In this breakdown, we're debunking the top mortgage industry myths that keep brokers stuck, overwhelmed, or operating with unnecessary pressure. Whether you're new or seasoned, these myths might be sabotaging your success without you even realizing it.
Let’s set the record straight.
Myth #1: “There’s Only One Way to Do This Business”
If you've been told, "This is how I did it, so it’s how you should do it," you’ve already heard this myth. People will tell you that if you’re not cold calling, door knocking, or buying suits, you don’t really want it.
🧠 Reality: There are a million ways to win in mortgage. Your personality, your market, your tech skills, your systems, your team, all play into what “works” for you.
“I’ve coached brokers who wear hoodies and run multi-million dollar pipelines, and I’ve seen suited-up LO veterans who are stuck doing things that stopped working five years ago.”
Don’t inherit someone else’s blueprint if it doesn’t align with how you operate. Build your business around your strengths.
Myth #2: “You Can’t Build a Mortgage Business Behind a Desk”
This one has stuck around way too long: the idea that unless you’re out “in the field,” you’re not really working.
🧠 Reality: You can absolutely build a thriving mortgage business from behind a computer as long as you’re doing the right work. Whether it’s generating leads, automating follow-ups, or creating systems, being desk-bound isn’t a disadvantage.
Today’s top brokers are leveraging:
CRM pipelines
Smart automations
Remote teams
Video calls and content
Social media funnels
If someone criticizes your time at the desk, ask them if they’ve ever built a scalable, repeatable system. Bet they haven’t.
Myth #3: “You Have to Chase Agents to Get Leads”
This is the most recycled advice in the game. And yeah, partnering with agents can be powerful. But here’s the thing...
🧠 Reality: It’s not the only way. In fact, for some, it’s not even the best way.
Some of the highest-performing brokers we’ve seen built their pipelines through:
Inbound marketing
Social proof on social media
Client referrals
Email marketing
Online lead generation
There are brokers closing 30+ deals a month who don’t even talk to agents. That’s not lazy, that’s strategic. What matters is not who you chase, but how you consistently create conversations about homeownership and financing.
Myth #4: “You Have to Be an Extrovert to Succeed”
Let’s kill this one for good: just because you’re not the loudest person in the room doesn’t mean you can’t close deals.
🧠 Reality: The best loan officers and brokers aren’t always extroverts. Many are adapted introverts, people who have learned how to show up when it matters but recharge alone.
Being good at sales is not about personality; it’s about:
Listening actively
Building trust
Knowing your product
Solving problems
Following through
You can be quiet, introverted, and still wildly successful in this industry, especially when you build the right systems around your strengths.
Myth #5: “Social Media Doesn’t Generate Real Business”
The most dangerous myth floating around mortgage forums and coaching calls today is that social media is a waste of time for mortgage pros.
🧠 Reality: Social media isn’t a nice-to-have. It’s one of the most efficient platforms for building trust, reach, and lead flow, especially in 2025.
“If someone tells you social doesn’t work, they’re either lying… or they suck at it.”
We’ve seen:
Reels that brought in 10+ new buyer conversations
Facebook posts that led to immediate referrals
LinkedIn DMs that turned into partnership meetings
TikTok leads for $5M jet memberships — so yeah, someone can buy a house after a Reel
Social media works but only if you work it right. It’s not about dancing or going viral. It’s about being visible, consistent, and valuable.
Myth #6: “Now’s Not a Good Time to Get Into Mortgage”
Between rates, uncertainty, and legacy voices saying the industry is too hard right now, this one creeps up a lot.
🧠 Reality: If you’re new? This might be the best time to start.
Why? Because:
The old ways don’t work as well anymore
You don’t have bad habits to unlearn
The tools available now are insane
Most of your competition is in their feelings, not in the game
Fresh eyes are an advantage. The game has changed, and the people who win now are the ones willing to play it differently.
The One Truth That Never Changes
Here’s the real secret behind every successful mortgage broker:
“Your success is tied to one thing: how many quality conversations you have about real estate and financing. That’s it.”
Conversations drive business. Whether they happen at a coffee shop, through DMs, on a Zoom call, or inside a CRM nurture, it’s all about getting in front of people and solving problems.
There’s no one-size-fits-all. There’s just what works for you, amplified over time.
The Wrap: Trust Strategy, Not Dogma
Every time someone tells you “this is the only way,” treat it as a red flag. Instead of chasing rigid formulas, ask:
Does this align with how I naturally operate?
Can I scale this without burning out?
Am I building my business or someone else’s?
Forget the myths. Forget the noise. Start having more conversations and lean into the strategies that actually fit the broker business you want to build.
Want to build a mortgage business that works for you?
Stay plugged into The MLO Project for real talk, tactical wins, and myth-busting truth every week.